Reaction to Nova Scotia Payday Loan Decision

Reaction has continued to trickle in this week to the July 31st decision of the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board to back a market-based approach to payday loan rate caps. The following is a summary of the recent media coverage:

The Chronicle Herald: URB sets payday loan limit

"The Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board has decided to let competition in the marketplace keep the costs of loans in check and on Thursday set the maximum cost of borrowing at $31 per $100 borrowed."
"'The maximum rate set by the board must be sufficiently high to allow the marketplace to function properly, while also preventing lenders from charging excessive fees and charges,' the board says in a 105-page decision released Thursday."
"The rate decision, the outcome of a five-day hearing in Halifax in January, contrasts sharply with a recent decision in Manitoba that set a much lower maximum borrowing rate."
"Nova Scotia’s board says 'it places no weight' on Manitoba’s decision, which debates the morality of payday loans."

The Canadian Press: N.S. regulator sets payday loan charge maximum at $31 for every $100 borrowed

"'Certainly there was a lot of dissatisfaction and negative publicity about payday lenders,' said [Municipal Relations and Service Nova Scotia Minister Jamie] Muir. 'The myth was out there that they take advantage of those who could least afford it. But, the [Utility and Review Board] report said in general the people who are using these services are typical Nova Scotians.'"
"'They got it right,' said Stan Keyes, president of the Hamilton-based Canadian Payday Loan Association. 'The board followed the evidence and from that determined the announcement that goes to protecting the consumer, and ensures there is a competitive viable industry in Nova Scotia.'"
"Still, consumer advocate David Cameron said he's unconvinced that the industry is as competitive as some industry representatives say it is. 'If there is competition it's not uniform throughout the province,' said Cameron. 'That's quite evident by looking in the phone book and seeing how many operators there are in certain towns or communities.' Cameron said the $31 maximum seems high, and that he hoped there would be more evidence gathered by the board before setting the rate. 'But there's a real problem in a rate not being set, too,' said Cameron. 'The board was faced with a difficult dilemma. There's no easy solution here, any decision made would be a difficult one.'"

CBC: N.S. regulator caps fees on payday loans